Real Estate news to know
The 'Escalation Clause' debate
Experts weigh in on whether to use bidding war tool
Experts weigh in on this bidding war weapon
By Jim Morrison, Boston Globe Correspondent
If you want to start an argument in a group of real estate agents, bring up escalation clauses.But in a competitive situation where there are multiple bidders, some buyers employ "escalation clauses" as a way to outbid the highest offer - but not by too much.
The typical offer is straight-forward. A buyer offers to pay a certain price for a home by a certain date, sometimes subject to mortgage, inspection, and other contingencies.
Many people have never heard of an escalation clause. That's because in a balanced real estate market, they're unnecessary. But in Greater Boston's inventory-starved seller's market, buyers and their agents need to get creative to be competitive. Enter the escalation clause.
There are agents who love them and agents who hate them, but until a more balanced market returns to Boston, we're going to continue to see them.Irene Bremis of iBremis Realty said she mostly represents sellers, but her opinion on escalation clauses is clear: "I am strongly against them. I don't like to reward bad behavior or punish good behavior."
Bremis said she prefers a straight offer because they're simpler and fair to all parties. She said all buyers should make their best offer. Using the analogy of a footrace, Bremis said she prefers to see all of the buyers run their best race, and may the fastest runner win. Escalation clauses are akin to saying you'll run fast enough only to beat the second-fastest competitor by one second, she said.
"When I see an escalation clause, it's typically in a multiple-bid situation," Bremis said. "You have to be careful to make every effort to be fair to all parties. If one offer has an escalation clause and the others don't, it can be tricky. And when there are multiple escalation offers, it can get really tricky."
Bremis said she presents all of the offers to her sellers, as the law requires, but recommends that they ask the buyers with escalation clauses to come back with their best, straight offer.
She said many sellers prefer a straight offer anyway.
She would use one, however, albeit reluctantly, if a buyer she was representing wanted to add one.
Attorney Kosta Ligris, founder and managing partner of the law firm Ligris, sees some legal issues with these offers. An offer to purchase is a legally binding document, Ligris said, and agents who stray too far from the lawyer-:-drafted standard forms provided by the Massachusetts Association of Realtors and other sales agent groups run the risk of being accused of practicing law without a license. They may put their clients at risk.
"It's tricky. It depends on how complex it gets," Ligris said. "If the offer just says, 'We're going to pay $5,000 over your next highest offer up to X amount', that's probably OK"
Ligris also said there are confidentiality issues with ascertaining what the next highest offer actually is and how legitimate it is.
"We've had situations where the sellers show the offer information to the buyer's agent or the buyer's attorney, but not the buyer," Ligris said. "Sometimes we get pushback on that. As an attorney or a buyer's agent, you owe your client a duty: What was that next highest offer, exactly? And was it a bona fide third party?"
Other agents, like Janice Sullivan of LAER Realty Partners in North Reading, consider escalation clauses just another item in an agent's toolkit to bring ready, willing, and able buyers and sellers together. In a hyper-competitive market, she said, an escalation clause can help a buyer stand out from the field and get the sellers more money than they might otherwise for their home.
"Oftentimes I receive multiple offers on houses, and more than one of them has an escalation clause," Sullivan said. "In that case, the escalation clause allows me to go back and negotiate the very best price and the very best terms possible, which is good for my seller client."
But escalation clauses can also help her buyers, she said.
"On the flip side, a buyer might be willing to pay up to $525,000 for a house," she said. "They can make an offer for $500,000 with an $2,000 escalation over the highest offer up to
$525,000, but they do not need to spend that much unless someone has outbid them. If
another buyer offers $510,000, they can get the house for $512,000."
Opponents of escalation clauses point out that in the above case, a buyer has already indicated their willingness to pay $525,000 for the property, so why wouldn't a seller in that case hold out for more?
But an escalation clause with no cap leaves a buyer vulnerable to having to pay more than they are comfortable paying.
Escalation clauses are here for the foreseeable future. Today's home buyers should talk to their agent and their attorney about whether or not they should consider incorporating them into their home-buying strategy.
Jim Morrison can be reached at JamesAndrewMorrison@gmail.com.
"I met Mark & Corinne at a property when the listing agent couldn't make it, so they filled in. I liked them right off. Although it turned out not be the house for me, they set their hearts on finding me the home of my dreams. I received intermittent emails about properties I might like, but never felt they were sending just any listing to me. They paid attention to my wants/needs, likes and dislikes. If I had questions or concerns and they didn't have the answer, they found out and got right back to me. They were tolerant of my desire to see any property more than once, and had a great understanding of the area to help weed out ones I wouldn't like. That is HUGE when you are an out-of-state buyer. I finally found the property I was looking for, and their negotiation skills and timely manner helped seal the deal. Even after the closing, they checked in to see how we were doing. I would highly recommend their services."
"We met with Mark and Corinne on January 2 and closed on our vacation home on February 26. They are passionate about the area and want to share that with others. They were incredibly response to all or our questions, calls and needs during the process. We thoroughly enjoyed working with them and would recommend them to anyone!!"
"I was looking for rei properties. Their response time and follow up was just incredible. First encounter I check a box to have a realtor call me. I closed my computer and the phone was already ringing, it was Corinne. The turn time on all calls and information were fantastic. Don't hesitate to use them."
"Mark & Corinne couldn't have been better! Great experience with them the whole way through and they often went above and beyond on many requests. A true delight."
"Tom and I are still in the process of locating our "forever home" so we cannot at this time comment on negotiation skills. However, I am guessing they are superb! Mark and Corinne are the perfect husband/wife team. We liked both of them from the "get go". They are both fun and easy to talk with, which is a great trait to have for any realtor when you are trying to describe your dream home. They are great listeners and catch on fast! They never tire! It is obvious that they both are in love with what they are doing and also their area. Choose Mark and Corinne - they won't disappoint you!"
"Dynamite duo that sold my property so quickly! Effective go-getters!!! I had the property listed in the past with another company and agent in an unsuccessful attempt to sell. I would recommend Mark and Corinne to anyone who wants to buy or sell!"
"it is not possible to have a better experience with a realtor. You feel that they are at your disposal 24/7. Not only do they anticipate what you need they respond in minutes when you contact them. I would never buy a property with anyone else! The phrase "dream team" describes them perfectly...but more importantly, they make you feel that you really matter to them!"
"We had the best experience buying our vacation home in North Conway with Mark and Corinne Ray. They were so professional, knowledgeable and really took time to get to know what we liked in a house/property. My husband and I really appreciated Mark and Corinne's honesty in every property we looked at, and they never pushed us to put an offer on anything that we did not love 100%. They showed us a great number of properties with patience and enthusiasm making us feel that we were their number one priority. I would highly recommend them to anyone either listing their property or buying in the North Conway area. They made it enjoyable and easy for us to find our dream vacation home!" micheledaly01 164 Birch Hill Rd, North Conway, NH [...]
"The best experience buying property in New Hampshire, thanks to Mark & Corinne Ray! They were honest, friendly and knowledgeable and made the whole real estate transaction easy, quick & painless!"
North Conway, NH 03860Phone603-986-7464Phone603-569-HOMEFaxEmailhomes@rayrealtynh.com